top of page

Passion vs. paycheque: Do we need an overhaul of university degrees?

11 hours ago
4 min read

The accusation levelled at creative arts and humanities degrees in recent years is that they are draining public finances by failing to obtain jobs that enable them to repay the astronomical student loans required to attend university.  


As a graduate in the social sciences, I understand where the objections stem from. Eighteen months after completing university with a publicly funded degree, I was no closer to obtaining a job with any relevance to the subject and have therefore had to spend further money on higher education. It is no surprise that 70% of sociology graduates go into a profession that has little relevance to the subject.   


In spite of this, sociology graduates are doing relatively well. A recent report by the Institute for Fiscal Studies highlights that they will receive around £47,000 in lifetime returns compared with non-graduates.


But for languages, philosophy and creative arts graduates, the picture is a lot bleaker. All three fields are currently experiencing negative returns, with creative and performing arts ranking the lowest with a -£40,000 deficit. 


This is a sad indictment of degrees that allow students to pursue their creative passions, rather than a degree in, say, finance- a mundane subject but one that can earn graduates vast swathes of cash. 


But the question remains- should the taxpayer foot the bill for these creative ventures? 


Though a large proportion of the £24 billion allocated annually to the Student Loans Company is eventually paid back by graduates, the long-run cost to the taxpayer (i.e. loans that will never be repaid, are written off or subsidised) is estimated at £4 billion per year. 


The issues do not end with debt repayment. A UK job market report by Adzuna found that UK graduate job vacancies have fallen by 45.6% annually, to a record low of 8,383 in July 2026. 


There are also wider issues that exacerbate the problem. Financing net-negative degrees can remove funding from subjects like medicine, artificial intelligence and engineering, which are imperative for future economic growth and generate considerable financial returns in the long run. 


The fundamental solution lies in greater awareness and a shift in how university education is advertised.  


It is no secret that secondary schools and sixth-form colleges are heavily judged on how many pupils go on to higher education, and in particular Russell Group universities. It is thus in schools’ best interests to promote university education rigorously and negate the aforementioned drawbacks. 


In the process, non-university paths like apprenticeships and vocational training have been sidelined. 


Andy Burnham has already promised a complete overhaul of the education system to tackle this, allowing children from as young as 14 to gain access to technical education, vocational training and work experience, to tackle youth unemployment. 


There is nothing to say that a similar overhaul couldn’t occur in higher education, whereby a substantial portion of the student finance allocated to creative arts degrees is instead invested in subsidised apprenticeships with local film production, theatre companies or photography agencies. Prospective students could also be directed by their schools to community theatre, independent productions and fringe festivals to build up a broad portfolio of work experience.   


This would ensure graduates enter the job market with experience under their belt, which has become far more valuable to employers than a degree certificate in recent years.   


Regarding philosophy, the issue is more complex. If the goal is to become a philosophy lecturer or academic researcher, the perceived wisdom is still to take the traditional route of a degree and further postgraduate studies.


But research shows that this is once again rarely the case. 20.3% of philosophy graduates find themselves in banking, HR or finance and 13.6% end up in retail, customer service and operations. 


This is not to diminish the importance of these jobs, but they mostly require different qualifications from philosophy or have little to do with it, making it pointless to saddle students with £27,000 of debt for three years' tuition and a maintenance loan. 


According to the IFS study, philosophy is currently ranking at a -£9,000 lifetime earnings deficit, so it is unlikely graduates can still go into these fields just by virtue of having a degree.    


To ensure potential philosophy students have sufficient passion to warrant this financial risk, institutions like The Open University and the University of Edinburgh provide free taster courses on basic concepts before committing to paid modules. Similar models should be employed in schools along with candid explanations of post-education employment prospects. 


Alternatively, academic pursuits like law (£177,000 lifetime earnings compared with non-graduates) or economics (£394,000) can allow students to grapple with deep philosophical principles like justice, rights and ethics, while simultaneously obtaining a higher-paid degree and increasing the likelihood of loan repayment.  


So the answer is: YES, we do need an overhaul of less financially beneficial higher education. 


But arguments like a blanket ban on funding are highly reductive, as they negate the value of these subjects outside of high remuneration.  


Instead, why not establish better frameworks, from the government level right down to discussions in the classroom, for students to adequately exercise their passions and eventually earn a living from them, while simultaneously reducing the £4 billion deficit in lost repayments every year?


Image: Wikimedia Commons/ Mauro Campedelli

No image changes made.

Comments


bottom of page