top of page

How ‘The Thick of It’ ruined British politics, or at least the optics of it

17 hours ago
4 min read

When watching any political coverage, whether that be an interview, a campaign speech or an episode of Question Time, it usually reminds me of Armando Iannucci’s cult classic The Thick of It. The dark comedy, broadcast between 2005 and 2012, centres on the workings of Whitehall and the British political system, based in the fictional Department of Social Affairs and Citizenship, or DoSAC. The department, headed by Ministers Hugh Abbot, Nicola Murray and Peter Mannion, serves as a microcosm for the dysfunctionality and ineptitude of the entire British political system, with Peter Capaldi’s Malcolm Tucker representing the Alastair Campbell-style communications enforcer (maybe Tucker will soon co-host a podcast with a colleague across the aisle). For those like myself who have watched every episode of the show multiple times, it is a byword for British politics. Once you see it, you cannot unsee it.


Iannucci has to be praised for his portrayal of British politics through The Thick of It, as it is both funny and extremely realistic. Its synopsis, highlighting the struggles and conflicts between politicians, spin doctors, civil servants and the media, was extremely apt in the years of the Blair government and after the Iraq War. The show also effectively centred itself on contemporary events; it released two specials in 2007 titled ‘The Rise of the Nutters’ and ‘Spinners and Losers’ based on a change in PM at the time of the Blair-Brown switchover. The 2009 third series depicted a dying government and an opposition preparing for power, and 2012’s fourth series shows a fraught coalition and an opposition without an identity, all with the overhanging shadow of a Leveson-style public inquiry. The show therefore closely followed political developments and satirised them; but worryingly for politics and politicians, the satire is extremely realistic, and sometimes less satirical than real-life events.


A perfect example is Ed Davey’s political stunts during the Johnson conservative government, where his ‘Boris Bubble’ and ‘Show Boris the Door’ stunts looked extremely Nicola Murray-esque, and you can almost see Davey’s versions of Ollie Reeder and Glenn Cullen giving him a thumbs up from behind the cameras. Similar can be said of any politician who goes on Newsnight and does not perform very well or looks nervous; these can be immediately compared to ‘blinky’ Ben Swain’s interview with Jeremy Paxman on the show. 


Politicians who visit trade or construction sites and wear a hard hat and a high-visibility jacket also resemble Hugh Abbot in his factory visit, where he praises the ‘fantastic landscaping’ of the site whilst looking frankly silly. This episode, broadcast in 2007, also corresponds in another way to real life, as Hugh’s adviser Glenn swears at a member of the public confronting him over an issue in a similar manner to Gordon Brown’s famous incident with Gillian Duffy on the 2010 election campaign trail in Rochdale. From displaying the conflict between the coalition partners: the ‘Robert Palmer tribute act’ Conservatives and ‘The Inbetweeners’ Liberal Democrats to portraying a grovelling political apology from Mannion for being a ‘fibreoptic failure’, the show hits the nail on the head.


Despite The Thick of It ending in 2012, politics has seemingly been a long-running series of The Thick of It in recent years. Writer and actor in the show, Will Smith, who played Mannion’s hapless advisor, ‘eight-year-old trapped in a twelve-year-old’s body’ Phil Smith, said that ‘it feels more like they [politicians] copy us’, demonstrated by a BBC mash-up before the 2017 election cutting together real-life clips and show scenes. In 2016, Iannucci himself said that he could not write The Thick of It any more since ‘politics feels fictional enough’ as it is, essentially saying that a satirical show was writing itself. One cannot forget that the ideas that Hugh, Glenn and Ollie come up with in the back of a car on the way to a press conference in the very first episode – a ‘national spare room database’ and ‘pet ASBOs’ – became real government policies.


A case in point for this is the Covid inquiry, or ‘The Thick of it on Steroids’, where profane messages, dismissive comments and awful statements were revealed from those at the centre of government during the country’s biggest crisis in 75 years. This led to comparisons with the show’s inquiry about the suicide of an off-screen character, Douglas Tickel (or ‘Mr Tickle’ to most characters) after his key-worker flat was sold off and he lived in a tent. Malcolm Tucker and Dominic Cummings were both questioned for their ‘revolting’ and ‘appalling’ manner in power, and embarrassing emails were read out to those being questioned – between ministers in real life and jokes made by advisors about Tickel in the show. If the Covid inquiry was put on BBC iPlayer alongside episodes of The Thick of It, no one would question its presence.


To anyone who has not watched the show, I implore you to watch it. Watch a few episodes, and then watch Question Time, Newsnight or listen to an interview on LBC – you will see the resemblance, and will never view politics the same way again. Maybe those in Westminster need to watch The Thick of It as well, like how Hugh was made to watch a ‘Zeitgeist tape’ by Malcolm, so that they can stop making politics look like a parody of a satire. Peter Capaldi summarised the problem of The Thick of It’s similarity to real-life politics perfectly, saying ‘The reason I’m not terribly keen on a revival is that it’s beyond a joke. And joking about it just in some way, takes the spotlight away from the problems. And I think that the problems are profound’. It depicted politicians unflatteringly, and politicians responded by acting worse than portrayed. It’s too realistic in modern-day politics to be truly funny, rather than a sad depiction of real-life events.


Image: Wikimedia Commons/ Timan2007

No image changes made.

Comments


bottom of page