top of page

Orkney Islands Search for Autonomy: Another Ripple in the UK's Rising Tide of Independence Movements

Updated: Mar 4

In a new challenge to British governance, the Orkney Islands Council is voting on a motion for greater independence next week. The islands are investigating "alternative forms of governance", likely looking to model themselves after Crown Dependencies like the Channel Islands and overseas territories like the Falkland Islands.

However, another possible future is being proposed - that of becoming a self-governing territory of Norway. A proposal spurred by their council leader James Stockan's assertion that the current UK system is "failing dreadfully" the people of Orkney.

Orkney, a historically Nordic and geographically remote archipelago off the northeastern coast of Scotland, believes it can no longer endure Westminster's and Holyrood's neglect. Despite significant contributions to the UK economy, especially in the burgeoning renewable energy sector, Stockan told the BBC that "the funding we get from the Scottish government is significantly less per head than Shetland and the Western Isles to run the same services - we can't go on as we are."

Councillors voted by a large majority on July 4th to look at a range of options to increase their autonomy and funding, alleging that Orkney had been unjustifiably deprived of hundreds of millions of pounds by ministers in Edinburgh. This economic inequity is symptomatic of a more significant issue - a systemic apathy towards provincial regions by Britain's metropolitan governments.

Devolution and independence have been impending realities in the United Kingdom for at least a decade. Irish reunification looks more likely than ever as Sinn Fein has taken power in The Northern Ireland Assembly. Furthermore, new census figures show that Catholics outnumber Protestants for the first time in Northern Ireland's history. Additionally, the desire for Scottish independence still lingers within a significant minority of the Scottish populace, despite the chaos surrounding the SNP.

Consider Cornwall, where only a narrow margin recently thwarted a devolution bid for a Cornish Parliament. Propelled by the Cornish nationalist party, Mebyon Kernow, the motion sought to start negotiations with the British government regarding a devolution deal similar to Wales and Scotland. Although defeated, the cross-party support garnered by this motion speaks volumes about the desire for increased regional autonomy - a sentiment shared in Orkney.

The recent call for a new form of governance in Orkney isn't an aberration but a manifestation of years of frustration. It suggests a willingness to sever the cord that ties them to a nation many believe no longer serves their best interests. While such a radical move may be shrouded in complexities, exploring a different path embodies a palpable defiance of Edinburgh and, ultimately, London's central power.

Orkney's independence debate signifies the UK's indifference toward its provincial members. The disinterest of the English government has fuelled independence politics across the British Isles. The appetite for autonomy from the UK and decentralising the power of London is not dissimilar to the anti-imperialist movements that have seen so many countries leave - or propose leaving - the Commonwealth in recent years.

A pattern has emerged. There is a growing disenchantment with the United Kingdom, and the increasing calls for regional autonomy are not coincidental. These movements testify that Britain's regional and national identities are increasingly at odds with London's political and economic dominance. The conservatism of England is regarded as an impediment to advancing the distinct socio-political aspirations of the United Kingdom's diverse regions.

These developments are emblematic of a faltering system that does not adequately protect its citizens. The march toward devolution and independence is the consequence of years of entitled metropolitan politics - the inevitable outcome of a long-standing power imbalance. The exploration of self-governance, as seen in Orkney, or the call for autonomous legislatures in Cornwall, are not merely political experiments. They're acts of survival in an indifferent nation.

Ultimately, devolution could serve as the much-needed catalyst for regional development, an opportunity for the distinct entities within the British Isles to break free of London's influence. The devolution of Orkney could usher in a wave of change that would redefine the political landscape of the United Kingdom, creating a more equitable and representative system of regional government.

Whether it's the possibility of Scottish independence, Irish reunification, Cornish devolution, or the Orkney's Islands joining Norway, independence is a clarion call for a new era of regional empowerment. The United Kingdom, in its traditional sense, needs to be reevaluated. It is imperative to reimagine the UK's political structures in order for it to become a fair and equal society. The political movements empowering independence and devolution will allow the country to progress. Increased regional autonomy may not be what London wants, but it is what Britain sorely needs.

Image: British County Flags

146 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page