The Milburn Review: a lost generation doesn't end at 24

Britain is facing a youth unemployment crisis. It is not a crisis unique to Britain, but one that successive governments have been extraordinarily slow in tackling, with youth unemployment in the UK standing at around 14%, the second highest in all OECD countries. Earlier this year, the news broke that over a million young people were not in education, employment or training–the so-called NEETs– with the problem reaching its highest level in a decade. On 17 November, Alan Milburn published his long-awaited review into the crisis, warning of the very real risk of a ‘lost generation’.
Milburn’s review includes recommendations such as increasing financial incentives for companies to hire 16–24-year-olds, or individuals who have been considered ‘NEETs’. These include payments of up to £5000 for small businesses and potentially an extra £2000 for employing young people who have been in care or who are disabled. On top of recommendations focussing on employers, Milburn recommends a revamp of Britain’s education system to better equip young people for when they enter the workplace. However, Milburn’s report also ventures into contentious territory with its recommendations including a wholesale transformation of the welfare system. His proposals to replace Personal Independence Payments (PIP) and Universal Credit with a ‘Youth Allowance’ for under-25s have proved controversial. Many, including the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, have criticised such a proposal, stating that young people who rely on PIP for financial stability could be worse off following this change. Such a transformation would disproportionately affect people with disabilities and caring needs, and it is unclear how reducing the amount of money spent on young people with disabilities or mental health conditions will alleviate youth unemployment. Milburn’s focus on welfare is certainly a surprise. Roughly half of all ‘NEETs’ do not claim any benefit whatsoever. This is not to suggest that welfare reform is irrelevant to the crisis, but it does raise questions about the extent to which the government's proposed changes address its underlying causes. If a significant proportion of young people are struggling to find employment without relying on welfare, then the solution must extend beyond reforming the benefits system.
One overlooked aspect of the youth unemployment debate is what actually constitutes a ‘young person’. Milburn’s report focuses virtually exclusively on 16–24-year-olds. There are no recommendations or considerations of other groups, such as 25- and 26-year-olds. Data shows that youth unemployment has been climbing since 2021, with spikes in 2022, 2024 and 2026. With COVID and AI unsurprisingly linked to the rising rate of youth unemployment, it is extremely bizarre that the generations most affected by those two elements are seemingly forgotten in Milburn’s report. A graduate born in 2002 will have turned 18 in 2020, undergone a largely online university experience, and graduated in 2023-2024, into a job market so heavily saturated by AI that it seems increasingly impossible to get on the career ladder. 26-year-olds, meanwhile, likely graduated into a still COVID-dominated landscape, also just in time for AI’s intrusion into the realm of employment. This is not to denigrate the experience of subsequent ages, but rather to highlight the failings of Milburn’s report. How can it be that the first age cohorts to be affected by this issue will continue to go unsupported? Just because an individual turns 25 does not mean they were not affected by the same issues as other age groups who will now be the focus of intense state-sponsored support. I find it ironic, therefore, that Milburn claims that his report highlights the risk of a lost generation, whilst falling short in addressing the experiences of another age group equally at risk of being ‘lost’ owing purely to the fact that they fall outside the rigidly defined 16-24 age range. In order to address this shortcoming, Milburn and the government must extend certain employment support provisions to 25–29-year-olds.
Whilst Milburn acknowledges the need for more personalised support, his report still approaches youth unemployment through a relatively narrow age-defined framework. The conditions that create an unemployed 16-year-old school leaver are very different from the conditions that create an unemployed 24-year-old graduate. Whilst both examples may stem from systemic educational failures, the way to tackle these issues should be tailored and specified to deal with a broad range of people. Research shows that almost a third of NEETs finished their education at GCSE level, while around 18% hold higher or degree-level qualifications. These are fundamentally different experiences, requiring different interventions. A young person who needs additional educational support will not necessarily benefit from the same interventions as a graduate struggling to secure their first professional opportunity. A million people might all have something in common–they might all be ‘NEETs’, but their individual experiences will vary extraordinarily and the way the government helps them must be tailored accordingly. Blanket measures to address all ‘NEETs’ will not effectively tackle those widely different perspectives.
Milburn’s report does represent a credible diagnosis, and has extremely useful observations and recommendations. Ensuring that employers are incentivised to hire younger people, huge investments in job support schemes, and a revamp of the mental health support available to young people are all huge positives for those struggling to find work or training. Furthermore, requirements for large employers to tell job applicants if they are unsuccessful would help in alleviating some job-search related stress. It is highly likely that Milburn’s recommendations – if implemented – would have a transformative effect on future levels of youth unemployment.
Milburn is right to warn of the risk of a lost generation. His recommendations offer an important starting point for addressing a crisis that has been neglected for far too long. But tackling youth unemployment requires more than incentivising employers and reforming welfare. It requires recognising that young people do not experience unemployment in the same way, nor do the consequences of a difficult transition into adulthood disappear when someone turns 25. If the government is serious about preventing a lost generation, its response must be sufficiently ambitious to recognise everyone at risk of being left behind.
No image changes made.
.png)



Comments