top of page

Paris 2024's Transgender Athletes: What is Fair?



The rules for transgender athletes at the Paris 2024 Olympics have just got a lot stricter. Now, they must complete their transition before age 12 to compete. This change aims to prevent any unfair advantages over cisgender female athletes. But will it ensure fair play? Let's break it down.


Laurel Hubbard, a weightlifter from New Zealand, made history at the Tokyo 2020 Games (held in 2021 because of COVID-19) as the first openly transgender athlete to compete. Her performance, however, wasn't stellar. She didn’t complete any of her lift attempts. Despite this, Hubbard won't be able to compete in Paris 2024 due to the new rules.


Previously, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) allowed transgender athletes to compete as women if their testosterone levels were below 10 nanomoles per litre for at least 12 months before their first competition. Now, the bar has been raised to protect cisgender women. This means transgender athletes face stricter criteria and more hurdles to qualify for the Olympics.


The World Athletics Council banned transgender athletes who transitioned after puberty from high-level female competition. World Aquatics followed, only allowing trans swimmers who transitioned before age 12. The decision was made based on scientific evidence suggesting that transitioning after puberty gives an unfair advantage. According to scientists, puberty triggers irreversible physiological changes that can give transgender women an edge in strength and endurance over cisgender women.


These new regulations have sparked a lot of controversy. Many transgender athletes feel they are being unfairly targeted and excluded. They argue that the rules are discriminatory and that they should be allowed to compete based on their gender identity. Or that the specifics of the new rules are effectively exclusionary for all transgender people.


On the other hand, supporters of the new rules believe they are necessary to ensure a level playing field for cisgender women. Factors such as testosterone levels, muscle mass, and bone density are significant factors in athletic performance. While hormone therapy can reduce testosterone levels in transgender women, it may not completely reverse the physical advantages gained during male puberty. This is the main argument used by those wanting stricter regulations.


However, critics point out that athletic performance is influenced by many factors, such as training, nutrition, and being physiologically prepared. They argue that focusing mainly on testosterone levels and puberty overlooks the complexity of what makes an athlete successful. Moreover, they emphasize the importance of inclusion and the right of transgender individuals to participate in sports.


The debate over transgender athletes is not new. It has been a contentious issue for years, with strong opinions on both sides. The new rules for Paris 2024 reflect ongoing efforts to balance fairness and inclusion in sports.


The focus on protecting cisgender women can be seen as sidelining the needs and rights of transgender women. Some argue that instead of imposing strict rules, sports organisations should work on developing more inclusive policies that allow all athletes to compete fairly.


In my opinion, these new rules are like a chocolate teapot, well-intentioned but likely to melt under scrutiny. Transgender athletes, like everyone else, deserve a chance to compete fairly. But, finding a fair balance is tricky. The conversation around transgender athletes in sports is far from over, and it’s clear that more research and dialogue are needed to create policies that are both fair and inclusive.


The Paris 2024 Olympics will test these new rules. Will they make the competition fairer? Or will they exclude deserving athletes? One thing is certain: the debate about transgender athletes in sports only continues to heat up.


We need to keep exploring ways to ensure that all athletes have the opportunity to compete on a level playing field, while also respecting the rights and identities of transgender individuals. The road to Paris 2024 will undoubtedly be a pivotal moment in this ongoing discussion, and the outcomes could shape the future of sports for years to come.



218 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page